Yesterday evening (27 October) Effingham Parish Council agreed to object to planning application 26/P/01289 submitted by Berkeley Homes for 600 dwellings on Effingham Lodge Farm, north of Lower Road. EFFRA will also strongly object.
There are currently already 26 objections on the Guildford Borough Council website. If you disagree with this application please submit an objection as every individual objection counts and helps make our planning authority aware of the community’s views. Please also share this post and encourage every member of your household and friends to submit an objection. Objections should be submitted by 20 November.
There are 3 ways to make an objection:
1 . Via the Guildford Borough Council (GBC) planning portal using the link below which takes you to the planning application. Then click on Comments and then Make a Comment. You will need to Log in to make a comment and register if you have not previously used the planning portal. This is a fairly simple process. The link is in blue to planning application 26/P/01289
2. Send an email to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk quoting the planning application 26/P/01289 and provide your full name and full postal address with postcode.
3. Write giving your full name and full postal address with postcode to:
Planning Enquiries
Planning Department
Guildford Borough Council
Millmead House
Millmead
GUILDFORD GU2 4BB
The first method is preferred by GBC and most quickly appears on the portal. Note the portal has been slow recently and sometimes goes down for a short period.
To be considered as objections comments should say “I object” be based on material planning considerations and should not include offensive or inflammatory comments. Names will appear on the website but addresses are screened out and not made public.
Objections are best written personally and there are some very good individual objections already posted, but possible planning grounds include:
- The land is Green Belt and cannot be classed as Grey Belt and available for development as claimed by Berkeley Homes as it is a continuation of the Green Belt that restricts the outward spread of Leatherhead, Fetcham and Bookham and satisfies Green Belt Purpose A. The development would therefore be inappropriate development in the Green Belt. If the land were to be classed as Grey Belt (which EFFRA believes would be incorrect) it would need to meet the “Golden Rules” for it to be agreed for development. EFFRA does not believe it meets these “Golden Rules”.
- 600 extra dwellings would represent an increase of 50% of the existing number of dwellings in Effingham. They would be concentrated on the site directly opposite the Howard of Effingham School and accessed from already busy roads. The roads in the village and other infrastructures including the Howard of Effingham School cannot cope with such an increase. Public transport is poor in Effingham and the increase in vehicle traffic from this proposed development will be unsustainable.
- Effingham is a historic village with a protected Conservation Area. This development will be out of character with the village and will damage the Conservation Area which it will border.
- 300 affordable homes are inappropriate in a small village with few local jobs and poor transport links. It is contrary to Government Policy which is to build them in urban areas with good infrastructure.


Thanks for this, Vivien.
Two points strike me.
1. Although the size is different, it seems to me that Eff. Lodge Farm site is actually identical to the site in Orestan Lane where the appln. for 37 homes was refused by GBC. All the reasons for that refusal should be applied by GBC to refuse Eff. Lodge Farm. I think this is a point worth making to GBC in our objections.
2. Have we discussed this appln. with CPRE? I would expect them to object strongly. I received a letter from CPRE today asking for money. On the envelope is written:
“We need to fix the broken housing formula for good. Stand up for our countryside.”
I object to the planning of 600 houses as the village is far too small to cope with that amount and the roads and infrastructure will not take the high volumn
Hi, the objection needs to be sent to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk. If you have not done so already then please copy your objection text and send from your personal email address. Thank you.
Dear Planning Officer,
I wish to formally object to planning application 26/P/01289 submitted by Berkeley Homes for the development of up to 600 dwellings on Effingham Lodge Farm, north of Lower Road, Effingham.
I believe this development is inappropriate in its proposed location, is excessive in scale and would have a significant and lasting detrimental impact on Effingham, its surrounding countryside and the quality of life of existing residents.
My objections are based on the following grounds.
**1. Inappropriate development of Green Belt land**
The proposed development would result in the loss of a substantial area of open countryside which forms an important part of the Green Belt around Effingham.
The Green Belt serves an essential purpose in preventing the unrestricted outward expansion of settlements, maintaining the separation between communities and protecting the countryside from urban sprawl.
This site is particularly important in maintaining the open character and separation of Effingham, Bookham, Fetcham and Leatherhead.
I do not accept that this land should be treated as suitable for development simply by describing it as Grey Belt. Its contribution to the purposes of the Green Belt must be properly and independently assessed.
The scale of this proposal would fundamentally alter the relationship between the village and the surrounding countryside. The loss of this land would be permanent.
**2. Excessive scale of development and damage to village character**
An additional 600 homes would represent a major expansion of Effingham, fundamentally changing the size, character and identity of the village.
Effingham is a historic Surrey village with a distinctive rural character, established community and protected Conservation Area.
This development would introduce a substantial urban housing estate into an area which currently contributes to the rural setting of the village.
The scale and density of the proposed development would be entirely out of keeping with the character of Effingham and would risk permanently eroding the qualities that make the village distinctive.
**3. Inadequate road infrastructure and increased traffic**
The existing road network is already under considerable pressure, particularly Lower Road and the surrounding roads serving Effingham, Bookham and Leatherhead.
The addition of up to 600 households would inevitably generate a significant increase in vehicle movements, putting further pressure on already busy roads and junctions.
There are particular concerns about traffic congestion, road safety, pedestrian safety and the ability of existing roads to accommodate the additional traffic.
The proximity of the site to the Howard of Effingham School makes this especially concerning, given the existing traffic movements associated with school drop-off and collection.
I do not believe the existing road infrastructure is capable of accommodating development on this scale without significant adverse consequences.
**4. Insufficient local infrastructure and school provision**
The proposal would place substantial additional pressure on local services and infrastructure, including schools, healthcare facilities, public services and community amenities.
Of particular concern is the absence of a replacement school in the proposals.
It is difficult to understand how a development of this magnitude can be considered sustainable without a clear and credible plan for providing the additional school places and supporting infrastructure required by the increased population.
The existing infrastructure in Effingham and neighbouring villages is already under pressure. The provision of a nursery does not address the wider educational needs of hundreds of additional households.
Any development of this scale must be supported by infrastructure that is delivered in advance of, or alongside, the housing rather than relying on existing communities to absorb the consequences.
**5. Poor public transport and unsustainable development**
Effingham does not have the level of public transport provision necessary to support a development of this size.
Without frequent and reliable public transport connections, residents would be heavily dependent on private cars for commuting, shopping, education and accessing healthcare.
This would undermine the stated objectives of sustainable development and result in increased congestion, pollution and carbon emissions.
**6. Impact on the natural environment and biodiversity**
The development would result in the loss of open countryside and would inevitably affect existing habitats, wildlife and the landscape.
The environmental consequences of building 600 homes on this site must be considered in their entirety, including the effects on existing wildlife corridors, trees, hedgerows, biodiversity and the wider rural landscape.
Any claimed biodiversity improvements should not be used to justify the destruction of an established natural environment.
**7. Drainage, flooding and pressure on water resources**
A development of this scale would create additional pressure on local drainage systems and water resources.
The Council must be satisfied that the proposals will not increase flood risk, create additional surface water problems or place unacceptable pressure on existing infrastructure.
These matters are particularly important given the permanent nature and scale of the proposed development.
**8. Cumulative impact on Effingham and surrounding communities**
The application must not be considered in isolation.
The cumulative impact of this development, alongside other existing and proposed development in the surrounding area, must be properly assessed.
The combined effect on roads, schools, healthcare, public services, the environment and the character of local communities could be considerable.
There must be a realistic assessment of the ability of Effingham and neighbouring communities to accommodate this additional population.
**Conclusion**
I recognise the need for new housing, including genuinely affordable housing. However, this does not mean that every available area of countryside should be considered suitable for development, regardless of its location, environmental importance or the capacity of existing infrastructure.
In my view, this proposal represents an excessive and inappropriate expansion of Effingham. It would cause lasting harm to the Green Belt, undermine the rural character of the village, increase pressure on already busy roads and place an unacceptable burden on local infrastructure and services.
The provision of 600 homes cannot be considered in isolation from the consequences for the existing community and the surrounding environment.
I therefore respectfully ask Guildford Borough Council to **REFUSE planning application 26/P/01289**.
I also request that this application is considered by the Planning Committee, rather than determined under delegated powers, given the scale of the development and the significant concerns it raises for the local community.
Yours faithfully,
James Lyons
10 Manor Gardens
Effingham
Surrey KT24 5PF
Hi, the objection needs to be sent to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk. If you have not done so already then please copy your objection text and send from your personal email address. Thank you.
Dear Planning Officer,
I wish to formally object to planning application 26/P/01289 submitted by Berkeley Homes for the development of up to 600 dwellings on Effingham Lodge Farm, north of Lower Road, Effingham.
I believe this development is inappropriate in its proposed location, is excessive in scale and would have a significant and lasting detrimental impact on Effingham, its surrounding countryside and the quality of life of existing residents.
Yours faithfully,
James Lyons
10 Manor Gardens
Effingham
Surrey KT24 5PF
Hi, the objection needs to be sent to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk. If you have not done so already then please copy your objection text and send from your personal email address. Thank you.
I do not believe that there is sufficient infrastructure and local resources to accommodate this development. In addition the local Howard of Effingham school would not have enough capacity to cope with a very significant increase in a larger local population.
Extremely disappointing and deeply frustrating. The Howard of Effingham was promised a brand-new school over a decade ago, which understandably meant investment in the existing buildings was put on hold.
Yet now, with contractors involved, it is difficult not to question whether those promises were ever genuine. The interests of pupils and the wider school community appear to have taken a back seat to commercial gain.
This should be about providing children with the school and facilities they deserve, not lining the pockets of those involved.
The pupils deserve better, and the community deserves transparency, accountability and answers.
So on that note I object to the build to the new estate.
Sir,
I strongly object to this proposal – I understand 600 extra homes would represent an increase of 50% of the existing number of dwellings in Effingham! They would be concentrated on the site opposite the Howard of Effingham School and accessed from already congested road. The roads in the village and other infrastructures including the Howard of Effingham School cannot cope with such an increase. Public transport is poor in Effingham and the increase in vehicle traffic from this proposed development will be completely unsustainable.
We all recognise the need for new homes but this proposal is untenable.
Hi, the objection needs to be sent to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk. If you have not done so already then please copy your objection text and send from your personal email address. Thank you.
The local villages will not be able to cope with not only the traffic but the infrastructure of so many new properties.
I object to the proposed building of 600 homes on land next to the Howard of Effingham School as proposed. The village simply cannot support the proposed development without the corresponding investment in local infrastructure such as schools, medical centres and local roads which can barely cope with current traffic flow on local roads which are narrow and already blighted by on street parking.
Hi, the objection needs to be sent to planningenquiries@guildford.gov.uk. Please copy your objection text and send from your personal email address. Thank you.
This is ridiculous !!! where are the children going to go to school,the Howard will very quickly become over subscribed.
Where are the extra facilities such as doctors surgeries, transport.
Our roads aren’t built for all the extra traffic ,they already struggle
We will no longer be the small pleasant friendly village that we are now ,l am all for progress but this is not progress What happened to the new school that you promised?
There is no forward thinking in this plan.